Home / Notes / After-sales
After-sales

A Return That Made Us Redesign the Carton

The product was fine. The box lost an argument with a sorting belt.

Melody
Melody Founder & CEO
Mar 27, 2026 · 5min read

In 2023, a shipment to Texas arrived with 11 of 240 cartons crushed on one corner. Nothing inside was broken. The distributor still refused them, correctly — a crushed box on a shelf reads as a damaged product.

We had done a drop test. On a single carton, onto a flat concrete floor, from 1 metre. What we had not done is a drop test on a palletised stack, which is what actually happens: the courier drops a carton onto the corner of another carton.

The fix was not thicker cardboard. It was an inner tray that held the vials 8 mm off the walls, so the corner could deform 8 mm before touching product. Carton cost went up 6%. Damage claims went to zero across the next 14 shipments.

If you are sourcing anything fragile, ask what the drop test was done against — a floor, or another carton. Only one of those two answers means anything in the real world.

Melody
Written by

Melody

Founder & CEO

In this industry since 2011 — the only one I have ever worked in. I answer every enquiry myself, and I sign off the batches that leave.

After-sales

Same series

Next step

Send the spec, get a real number

Not a catalogue price. The number after your quantity, your packaging and your port are in the calculation.