I have watched buyers lose money in this industry for fifteen years. Almost none of it was lost on unit price. It was lost in the gap between “sample approved” and “goods landed” — a gap where nobody is lying, and everybody is assuming.
These are the six questions I would ask, in this order, before signing anything.
1. Which exact line will run my order?
Not which factory. Which line, and who supervises it. A factory with four lines may run your 3,000-piece order on the line that is normally idle, staffed by whoever was available. Ask for the supervisor’s name and the line number, and put it in the contract. If they hesitate, the order is going somewhere they have not decided yet.
2. Is the sample from the same tool as the production run?
Prototypes are often made on a tool that is later retired. The sample you approved may have come from a machined aluminium insert; the production run will come from a hardened steel tool that has different gate locations and different shrinkage. Ask explicitly: will the production cavity be the same cavity that produced this sample? And ask to see a first-article inspection from the production tool before the bulk run starts.
3. What is the AQL, and who does the inspection?
“We check everything” is not an answer. Ask for the AQL level, the sample size, and whether inspection is in-house or third-party. For microneedling products I would not accept anything looser than AQL 1.0 for critical defects (needle integrity, sterility barrier) and 2.5 for major. Also ask who pays for a third-party inspection when it fails — if the answer is you, the supplier has no incentive to pass.
4. If a batch fails, what happens to my money?
Ask about the rework and replacement policy before the deposit, not after the failure. Specifically: is the deposit refundable if the first article fails, who pays freight on a replacement, and what is the time limit for raising a claim after arrival. A supplier who has never been asked this will improvise an answer. A supplier who has a standard answer is a supplier who has been through it.
5. What is the actual lead time, and what breaks it?
Every factory quotes the good-weather lead time. Ask what the lead time becomes when the needle plate etching line is down, or when Chinese New Year falls in the middle of your production window. Ask which component has the longest inbound lead time — it is almost always the foil pouch or the custom carton, not the device. Then build your launch date around that component, not around the device.
6. Who answers the email in month eighteen?
This is the one that matters most and gets asked least. Ask: if I have a quality complaint twenty months from now, who do I write to, and will that person still be here? Then ask for that person’s name and direct address, and put it in the file. The reason this matters is that your product’s third year is entirely dependent on whether someone at the factory still remembers your tool.
Price is negotiated once. Support is negotiated every time you need it, and by then you have no leverage.
One more, for free
Ask them to write the answers in an email rather than answer on a call. Not because email is more formal, but because a supplier who will not put a commitment in writing has told you something important about how month eighteen will go.
None of these questions make you a difficult customer. They make you a customer whose file is complete — and files that are complete get served first when a factory is busy.
Scan to chat on WhatsApp
Scan to add on WeChat